kapujesz?
Wróć do wydaniaUkraina

Zelensky says security guarantees are still not on paper

Pałac Maryjski w Kijowie
Zdjęcie ilustracyjne. Fot. Maksym Kozlenko, CC BY-SA 4.0, zmieniono rozmiar i kadr

Volodymyr Zelensky is the president of Ukraine. On 21 November, he talks to reporters. He says he has no written promise about the security of his country.

The United States talks about a guarantee like in NATO. In NATO, an attack on one country is an attack on all countries. A US envoy, Jared Kushner, says Russia is comfortable with this idea. But according to Russian state media, a Russian deputy minister says no to a form of NATO membership for Ukraine.

Zelensky wants answers on paper. Who will help Ukraine? How? He wants guarantees for many years. For him, NATO is still the best option.

Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, spoke to reporters on 21 November. He said that he has not yet seen written commitments about security guarantees for his country.

Two days earlier, in Berlin, the US envoy Jared Kushner talked about guarantees similar to Article 5 of NATO. This article says that an attack on one member is an attack on all members. Kushner said that Russia was comfortable with this idea. But according to Russian state media, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov rejected any form of quasi membership for Ukraine.

Zelensky wants to know who will defend Ukraine and how. He says that the answers must be on paper. He also wants guarantees for many years, not only during Donald Trump's term. For him, joining NATO is still the best option. He accepts that this is not certain.

Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, said on 21 November that he has still not seen written commitments explaining how the proposed security guarantees for Ukraine would work.

The debate began on 19 November in Berlin. There, the US envoy Jared Kushner said Washington was open to guarantees modelled on Article 5 of NATO, under which an attack on one member is treated as an attack on all. Kushner added that Russia was comfortable with the concept. However, according to Russian state media, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov rejected any form of quasi membership of the alliance for Kyiv.

Zelensky is asking who would belong to this group of countries, how it would defend Ukraine and whether it would be ready to stop the aggressor. He also wants the guarantees to last longer than Donald Trump's term in office, «preferably forever» or at least for decades.

The president argues that membership of NATO remains the best option and would be cheaper for everyone. Without it, he estimates that Ukraine would need an army of about one million people. He admits, though, that joining is uncertain, and an invitation requires the agreement of all members.

Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, told reporters on 21 November that he has yet to see any document setting out how the security guarantees now under discussion would actually function. He stressed that any such commitments must be set down on paper, because Ukraine still lacks clarity about what they would involve.

The discussion gained momentum on 19 November in Berlin, where the US envoy Jared Kushner, during talks with European leaders, said that Washington was open to guarantees modelled on Article 5 of NATO. That clause treats an attack on one member as an attack on all of them. Kushner also said that Russia was comfortable with the concept. The message from Moscow sounded different, however: according to Russian state media, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov rejected any form of quasi membership of the alliance for Ukraine.

Zelensky's questions are practical. He wants to know which countries would make up the group offering protection, how it would defend Ukraine and whether it would be prepared to push back an aggressor. He also insists that the guarantees must outlast Donald Trump's term in office. In his words, Ukraine needs them not for two years but «preferably forever», or at least for decades.

The president still regards membership of NATO as the best protection, arguing that it would strengthen the alliance and lower defence costs. Without it, he estimates, Ukraine would need an army of about one million people, along with aircraft, artillery, missiles and air defence. He concedes, though, that accession is uncertain and depends on how and when Russia's war ends. Although allies reaffirmed Ukraine's path to membership at their 2024 summit in Washington, an invitation requires the consent of every member, and no such consensus exists at present. For now, the form that Ukraine's future protection might take remains an open question.

Kliknij dowolne słowo, żeby zobaczyć tłumaczenie.

What does Zelensky say he has not seen yet?